How A Housing Project Gave Third Avenue Its First Neighborhood Bistro
September 3, 2026
September 3, 2026
Walk past 1123 Third Avenue on a Friday night and you will likely find a line at the door. Inside, past the marble counters that once processed deposits and mortgages, a thick iron vault door now opens onto a private dining room. The restaurant calls it The Vault. Order the Crab Blossom or the Parisian Gnocchi and you would never guess you are sitting in a building that spent most of the last century as a bank.
That restaurant is Marée, French for tide, and it officially opened in downtown Spring Lake this past July. Local coverage has called it downtown's first true neighborhood bar and bistro, a distinction worth sitting with for a town that has had upscale dining rooms for decades but never quite this kind of place: a bar you could walk to on a Tuesday, not just a special-occasion table you book weeks out.
Here is the part most people ordering the Bouillabaisse Grits do not know. Marée did not happen because a restaurant group scouted Third Avenue, liked the foot traffic, and signed a lease. The building came first, and it came from the Borough itself.
Spring Lake bought the 125-year-old former bank building to create affordable housing on the upper floors. Once that deal was done, the town turned to residents and asked what they wanted to see on the ground floor. The answer became Marée, opened by chef and longtime Jersey Shore restaurateur Marilyn Schlossbach, who has run restaurants at the Shore for more than 35 years, alongside developer Bret Morgan, who led the buildout, financing, and technology behind the space. The two structured it as a separate partnership from their other hospitality projects, a deliberate choice that kept this specific building's civic backstory attached to this specific restaurant.
That sequence matters. It means the ground floor at 1123 Third was never actually available to any restaurant group chasing a trendy location. It was allocated through a public process tied to a housing project, which is a different kind of scarcity than the ordinary commercial real estate that governs which restaurants open where.
Spring Lake covers 1.31 square miles and holds fewer than 3,500 residents. There is no room to add storefronts to Third Avenue, only room to wait for one to turn over, and turnover here tends to be generational rather than entrepreneurial.
Consider what has stayed put:
None of these businesses left to make room for something new. They are simply still there, which is normal for this street. A new full-service restaurant claiming a storefront on Third Avenue is rare enough that it makes the local news, and Marée did.
The more ordinary churn has been happening a block over on Morris Avenue instead. Nick + Sons Bakery opened there in 2021 and has become known for croissants that tend to sell out by mid-morning in summer. Arugula Modern Cuisine, also on Morris, brought in a chef whose menu draws on cooking traditions from China, Japan, England, Brazil, Italy, India, Germany, and Cuba, a genuinely wide range for a two-block commercial district. If you want to see where Spring Lake's food scene actually experiments, Morris Avenue has been doing that work quietly while Third Avenue held steady.
None of this happened in a vacuum. Spring Lake already has a summer rhythm that predates Marée by years. For four Wednesday evenings in late July and early August, the Business Improvement District closes Third Avenue between Washington and Passaic Avenues to cars from 5 to 9 p.m. for live music and family activities, an event the town calls Spring Lake Summer Nights. Divine Park hosts its own free summer concerts on other nights, drawing residents across the footbridges for an evening on the lawn.
What Third Avenue lacked, until this summer, was a place for that same crowd to sit down for dinner after the music stopped without driving to Belmar or Sea Girt. Marée's bar seating and walk-in policy make it a plausible answer to that specific gap, one created by a schedule of events the town already runs every year, not by anything the restaurant itself invented.
Two Chamber-run festivals bracket the summer here. The Irish Festival, held earlier this year, centers on Morris Avenue with a food court, a beer and wine garden, and an Irish soda bread contest judged out of the Irish Centre at 1120 Third Avenue. The Italian Festival returns to Morris Avenue every September with its own food court and live music through downtown, a tradition the Greater Spring Lake Chamber of Commerce has run for years. For residents counting down the last weeks of summer, that festival is the next fixed point on the calendar, and it will be the first one to fall after Marée's opening summer.
The pattern underneath all of this is worth remembering the next time a storefront on Third Avenue sits empty for a season and residents wonder what might fill it. In a town this small, with this little available ground floor space, the answer sometimes has less to do with what a restaurant group wants to lease and more to do with what the Borough decides to do with a building it already owns. Marée is the clearest recent example. It may not be the last.
If you already know this street, this stretch of Morris Avenue, and the sound of a Wednesday night with the road blocked off for music, you know Spring Lake in a way that does not show up on a listing sheet. When that knowledge turns into a question about property here, whether buying, selling, or simply understanding what a specific block is actually worth, Chris Pizzola works this market year-round and is glad to talk through what you're seeing.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Providing his clients with a true luxury brand and representation is the foundation of his business. Contact him today to find out how he can be of assistance to you.